Best German Casinos – Top online providers and bonuses v683q

Home » Best German Casinos – Top online providers and bonuses

Online gambling in has undergone many changes in recent years. And still is. For many players it is rather unclear whether it is legal to place bets in the best German casinos or not. Until recently, you could find the best online casino in with just two clicks. Now things are getting more and more complicated.  1355k

We rinsed out the details and created this page to let players know everything about the German casino sites. If you want to know how to find the best online casinos for German players, you can read all the information here. You can also learn how to bet for real money in every casino and what you can expect from a German online casino.

Casino Bonus Rating Visit
22BET
1.
22BET
Welcome Bonus
100% Up To €300
On Your First Deposit
Min. Deposit Is €1. Wager: X50 the bonus & deposit amount. 18+ Gamble Responsibly. T&Cs Apply.
4.9 rating
9.72
Read Review Min. Deposit Is €10. Wager: X25 the bonus & deposit amount The max. bonus amount for this promotion is €500 General & Conditions Apply. Please Read Bonus At Casino's Promo Page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly. T&Cs Apply.
BC.Game Crypto Casino
2.
BC.Game Crypto Casino
Up to 4th deposit bonus
up to 180%
+ Gamble Responsibly.T&C apply
4.9 rating
9.70
Read Review Unknown T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the BC.game' T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
Spinly Casino Review
3.
Spinly Casino Review
100% Welcome bonus
up to 3,500 µBTC
Responsibly.T&Cs apply
4.8 rating
9.68
Read Review General T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the Spinly's fun T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
Yoju casino online review
4.
Yoju casino online review
First deposit bonus
100% up to 250 €/$ + 20 Free spins
+ Gamble Responsibly.T&C apply
4.8 rating
9.65
Read Review 40 times wagering. No restriction to maximum payout, General T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the Yojus' T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
Oshi casino
5.
Oshi casino
Free spins
100 FS on your first deposit
+ Gamble Responsibly.T&C apply
4.8 rating
9.64
Read Review 45 times wagering. General T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the Oshi's T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
Everygame Sportsbook, Casino and Poker
6.
Everygame Sportsbook, Casino and Poker
First deposit bonus
max 100% up to 750 CAD/USD
+ Gamble Responsibly.T&C apply
4.8 rating
9.64
Read Review Wager 30 times bonus amount. Minimum deposit 25 USD/CAD, General T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the Evergames T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
Bspin Casino
7.
Bspin Casino
Welcome Bonus
Get 100% Up To 1 BTC
+ 50 Free Spins
T&Cs Apply.
4.8 rating
9.63
Read Review minimum deposit of 1.000 μBTC. Wager X45. This offer is valid for 30 days from the moment of initial deposit. General & Conditions Apply. Please Read Bonus At Casino's Promo Page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly. T&Cs Apply.
SlotWolf Casino
8.
SlotWolf Casino
Welcome Bonus
Get Up To €3000
HighRoller Package
On Your First 3 Deposits. 18+ Gamble Responsibly
4.8 rating
9.63
Read Review Bonus Available On Your First 3 Deposits. 1st, 2st, 3th As Shown 100%, 70%, 110% Bonus. Min. Deposit Is €300. Please Read The General Bonus . 18+ Gamble ResponsiblyT&C Apply
Betwinner
9.
Betwinner
Welcome Bonus
Up To €100 Sports betting bonus and up to €300 casino bonus
18+ Gamble Responsibly. T&C apply
4.8 rating
9.63
Read Review Bonus wager 5x in accumulator bets, Max. bonus amount €100, General Bonus And Standard & Conditions (T&C) apply. Please Read Details At Casino’s Offer Description. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
Wild Tornado Casino
10.
Wild Tornado Casino
Welcome Bonus
Up To €1000/0.1 BTC
+100 Free Spins
18+ Gamble Responsibly. T&Cs Apply.
4.8 rating
9.61
Read Review The minimal amount for withdrawal is 50€ or an equivalent. The maximum amount for withdrawal depends on the payment method you use. General & Conditions Apply. Please Read Bonus At Casino's Promo Page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly. T&Cs Apply.
Playzax casino
11.
Playzax casino
Alternative bonus
300% up to 60 €/$
18+ Gamble Responsibly.T&C apply
4.8 rating
9.60
Read Review 90 times wagering bonus amoun. Table games does't count for wagering, General T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the PlayZaxs' T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
Fastpay Casino
12.
Fastpay Casino
Welcome Bonus
Get Up To €100
100 Free Spins
18+ Gamble Responsibly.
4.8 rating
9.59
Read Review Minimum Deposit €20, Wager Requirements X50. 20 Free Spins Daily, 5 Days In A Row. No Bonus Code Needed. 18+ Gamble Responsibly. Please Read Full . T&C Apply
True Flip Casino
13.
True Flip Casino
Welcome Bonus
Get Up To €1000
+ Up To 150 Free Spins
T&Cs Apply.
4.8 rating
9.59
Read Review Min. Deposit: €20 The maximum amount of the Bonus is 40mBTC / €300 or the equivalent in other currencies. Wager: X35 Different games contribute differently to the wagering requirements. Check The list on Bonus Policy page. General & Conditions Apply. Please Read Bonus At Casino's Promo Page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly. T&Cs Apply.
Xspin Crypto online casino Review – Xspion io
14.
Xspin Crypto online casino Review – Xspion io
100% Welcome bonus
up to 0.04 BTC
Responsibly.T&Cs apply
4.8 rating
9.58
Read Review General T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the XSPIN's fun T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
Wagered Casino Review
15.
Wagered Casino Review
Deposit 30$
Get 50 free spins worth $10 and $10 free sports betting without wagering
Responsibly.T&Cs apply
4.8 rating
9.58
Read Review General T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the Wagered Casino's T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.

Gambling online 5m1x3q

Internet gambling is becoming increasingly popular. If you’d like to try your luck and don’t know exactly where to start, you’ve come to the right place. Here you will find an overview of the best online gambling websites that are also available in German. However, you should know that these providers are not based in . But that’s not a bad thing, because gambling is regulated in many countries and the operators have a corresponding license.

Finding the best online casino isn’t that difficult either. We will be happy to help you with the search and give you tips on what you should pay attention to when you with a provider. On this page you can find the best online casinos for German players. You can expect generous bonus offers, high-quality games, a safe environment and competent customer service.

Each casino was individually tested and then rated. The detailed casino reviews give you information about bonuses, payout speed, bonus wagering requirements, advantages and disadvantages and a detailed list of available games. You can also search for the best providers that offer live casinos , mobile casinos, sign up bonuses or flash versions.

Best German Casinos 5y305l

4.9 rating
First Deposit Bonus - 100% Up To €300
18+ Gamble Responsibly.
T&Cs Apply
Min. Deposit Is €10.
Wager: X25 the bonus & deposit amount
The max. bonus amount for this promotion is €500 General & Conditions Apply. Please Read Bonus At Casino's Promo Page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly. T&Cs Apply.
4.9 rating
Welcome Bonus - up to 180%
18+ Gamble Responsibly.
T&Cs Apply
Unknown T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the BC.game' T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
4.8 rating
100% bonus on first deposit up to 3,500 µBTC .
T&Cs Apply
General T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the Spinly's fun T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
4.8 rating
Welcome bonus 100% up to 250 €/$ + 20 Free spins
18+ Gamble Responsibly.
T&Cs Apply
40 times wagering. No restriction to maximum payout, General T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the Yojus' T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
4.8 rating
Casino welcome bonus 100% up to 100 €/$
18+ Gamble Responsibly.
T&Cs Apply
45 times wagering. General T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the Oshi's T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
4.8 rating
Welcome Bonus - 100% up to 750 CAD/USD
18+ Gamble Responsibly.
T&Cs Apply
Wager 30 times bonus amount. Minimum deposit 25 USD/CAD, General T&Cs (T&C) apply. Check the Evergames T&C page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly.
4.8 rating
Welcome Bonus - Get 100% Up To 1 BTC & 50 Free Spins
18+ Gamble Responsibly
T&Cs Apply
minimum deposit of 1.000 μBTC.
Wager X45.
This offer is valid for 30 days from the moment of initial deposit.
General & Conditions Apply. Please Read Bonus At Casino's Promo Page. 18+ Gamble Responsibly. T&Cs Apply.
4.8 rating
HighRoller Package - Get Up To €3000 Welcome Bonus
On Your First 3 Deposits
T&Cs Apply
Bonus Available On Your First 3 Deposits. 1st, 2st, 3th As Shown 100%, 70%, 110% Bonus. Min. Deposit Is €300. Please Read The General Bonus . 18+ Gamble ResponsiblyT&C Apply

Online casino sites in 3y2wa

If you are already on this site, you have probably searched for internet casinos in to play German free spins or for real money to bet. Even if there is a large selection of online casinos today, it is not always easy to find the right one, especially if you want to play in the best German online casinos. Some of the casinos are not accepted in the country, some do not offer the required number of games and others simply do not look reliable enough. So how do you find the / friendly online casinos that match the case?

There are two options: you can either read the reviews in all German online casinos to choose the right one, or you can rely on the experienced Betandslots team, which already collects all of the best rated online casinos in on the market Has. In addition to our own experience and expertise, we use the unique algorithm, with which we can only show the best online casino depending on the location. We also take into all the important points that every online casino in should take to ensure that players get the best and safest gaming experience without wasting time on the fruitless search for the best online casino in .

How to select the best German online casino 5033j

Even if we designate the six main categories with a certain generic term, each of these categories has further sub-ratings that are fed into our rating algorithm. In this way, a total of 30+ partial evaluations are included in the calculations and ensure that we can present you with an accurate result.

  • Security & reputation: data encryption, license, certificates from independent organizations, player reports, number of customer complaints submitted
  • Games: number, quality, popularity, payout percentages and timeliness of the offered slots, jackpots and live casino games
  • : speed of reaction and competence of customer service
  • Bonuses & promotions: amount and fairness of the welcome bonus , further offers for existing customers such as free spins, loyalty and VIP clubs
  • experience and Mobile game: game selection and quality, software, usability and functionality of the mobile casino. Functionality and interface of the casino software
  • Payment methods: Reliability and average speed of withdrawals, offer of withdrawal methods, offer of popular payment methods in

As soon as we have calculated an overall rating for the casino, the values ​​and results are entered into our database and the casinos that top our ranking appear directly in the leaderboards with our recommended providers here on betandslots.bingoextra.net . We always update information and ratings of the casinos, for example when a provider adds new online casino games to the program or changes its bonus. So you and we always stay up to date and are provided with authentic and current online casino reviews.

Licensing 1k3z24

Whether you want to play video poker or online slots in , the online casino license is required. Such licenses can only be issued by the state of Schleswig-Holstein. For those who are not really interested in legal gambling restrictions and would like to play games of chance in international online casinos, we still recommend paying special attention to the license. This information should be clearly stated on the casino website to prove that all games are fair and that Online Casino Deutschland is legal and reliable and has been approved by the institution.

Is there a German gambling license? No, the only gaming license from comes from Schleswig-Holstein and is only valid for the federal state and its citizens. However, this does not mean that all other players run on hot iron or make themselves punishable. The European licenses from Malta and Gibraltar apply to German players from other federal states , since there is no uniform regulation in . From July 2021, a regulation for online gambling is to come into force, which is intended for all German citizens.

As long as this is not the case, online casinos with a license from Malta or Gibraltar are just as legal as a provider with a German license – that means the EU’s freedom to provide services. So players should make sure that they play in licensed online casinos. These are subject to strict guidelines and are, for example, obliged to always pay out winnings, keep customer funds safe and guarantee a reputable and safe gaming environment.

Games 66g38

If you opt for the German casino online, you have to take a look at the software presented on the website of the casino. Large and well-known providers of online casino games never allow their products to be offered by suspicious online casinos. So when you see the Deutschland Casino online with the games from IGT, Microgaming, Novomatic, Merkur, Bally Wulff, NetEnt etc., you can be sure that it is a good casino.

Customer service 6y6t5h

Even if you play in the best online casino for Germans and the casino has a great interface and the most popular online casino games, you can still ask questions about the payment process, the deduction of winnings, an online casino no deposit bonus , an online casino mobile payment , an online live casino or other game processes. A good customer that can answer all these questions is the special feature of the ten leading German online casinos, which makes them more comfortable for the players and attracts new customers. We only include the online casinos accepted in with 24/7 customer in the list, so that players always have someone to help them.

Bonuses and special offers 725468

Another important thing that distinguishes the top 10 online casinos in is the selection of special offers and casino bonuses. These include the welcome bonus with a deposit, or in some occasions the online casino no deposit bonus code, with which you can try out some of the online games online for free, and the free spins for slot machines. The online casino no deposit bonus is good for doing a German casino test before betting with real money. A generous casino bonus doesn’t just boost your balance, but also your winning chances while prolonging your experience and entertainment.

Especially as a new customer, you can already get a lot of casino bonus money. With this bonus money you can play longer and therefore have more chances of winning. It is not possible to answer a general question about which is the best casino bonus. It depends on what your preferences are and which games you want to play with the bonus money.

If you are playing with casino bonus money, you should first look at the bonus wagering requirements and familiarize yourself with the general bonus rules. You can then avoid misunderstandings. You can also find an overview of all bonus types on our website .

experience, languages 266na

Finding a EUR online casino is not that difficult, but what do you have to do if you want to deposit in a different currency? Our list includes online German casinos where players can place bets in different currencies and use the website in different languages. This is how new online casinos in are getting closer, regardless of which language the players speak and where they live.

Payment options and currencies 6b2d3a

For many players, the choice of payment methods available is a very important point when choosing the best German online casino to bet real money. Most of the approved and reliable deposit options that an online casino can use to make withdrawals are Visa and MasterCard cards, PayPal and bank transfers.

Playing in an online casino is a matter of trust. You need to be sure that you are in good hands on the gambling website before you deposit your money there. Fortunately, there are a few criteria you can watch out for so that your online game doesn’t turn out to be a letdown.

How to choose the best German casinos? 1q4542

First of all, you should only play on websites that have a valid license . Usually the license number and the issuing country are always given below on the website. The providers we present are all fully licensed and are regularly checked for fairness. So you don’t have to worry with us that the online casino is cheating.

Then you should think about what is important to you when playing, for example whether you want to play with or without bonus money or like to play tournaments. Since each casino has a different offer, it is worth comparing and trying out several casinos.

At Betandslots we have well-coordinated team of experts from the gaming industry . For many years we have been following the development of internet casinos and were also able to get to know one or the other black sheep among the reputable providers. It has been our goal to alert players for any black sheep in the industry which offer poor gambling opportunities.

To make this possible, we test every provider equally and fair. With our detailed test method we are able to filter the best online casinos. We are aware that not every provider has the same strengths, just like every player has their own preferences. That is why, in addition to the best casinos, we generally have leaders for various test criteria. Some value a no deposit bonus, while others want the best customer service available. We have them all!

5 criteria for our best German casinos 4h1g1m

  • Official and well-known licenses from Malta, Gibraltar, or Schleswig-Holstein
  • Large selection of games, including live casino
  • Many payment option and SSL encryption
  • -friendly design & mobile casino
  • High ratings in all areas of our casino test

Gambling laws in 2i6u6l

Are online casinos legal in ? If you ask if an online casino is allowed in , you get bad news. According to the German online gambling laws, which are set out in the Intergovernmental Treaty on Online Gambling, all types of online gambling are considered illegal. The good news is that the market isn’t strictly controlled. In addition, there may be positive changes to the online gambling law in that give international casino operators more space and make the entire gambling industry in more friendly to players.

So, is online casino legal in ? Gambling has always been a controversial topic in . There were no online gaming laws in until 2008. Online gambling, including all types of sports betting and poker rooms, was illegal in . According to the new legislation on gambling law in , it was forbidden to host the international online casinos and to grant them access. However, no German player has ever been prosecuted for betting in the EUR casino.

German states laws 4k1d72

A German state quickly had its own gaming legislation that legalized gambling, so that every casino can legally work in . Although these laws were only in effect for about a year, the state managed to award ’s online gaming licenses to 50 sports betting companies and online casinos, which are the only legal online casinos in today. These German online casinos have their license valid until 2018. Then the new online gambling authority in comes into force to take the first steps towards introducing the legitimate online casinos for German players and to make playing in the online casino legal for real money in .

Despite the complicated legislation, online casino games are very popular in and bring the state treasury (including offline casinos, lotteries, poker and sports betting) around 16 billion euros. While it’s not that easy to find a secure online casino in or a legal casino in , German gamers who are of legal age (the gambling age in is 18 and 21 years old, depending on a state) enjoy international ones Casinos to which they have access. The government does not gambling in these casinos. So if something happens, it’s not the government’s problem. For this reason, it is very important that you stick to the renowned online casinos in that you can find on this page.

Online gambling in has long been a point of contention among the federal states. The attempt to regulate gambling failed in the past, especially because the countries did not agree and the EU Commission also classified the proposed laws as unconstitutional.

Gambling laws reform i65l

The international gaming providers see the German market as a gray area. Even if internet gambling is illegal, they offer the gambling to German players and are only tolerated by the state, since there is no legal way to take action against these providers. Even if it is illegal in , the players have rights when playing on the websites licensed in the EU and there are the best slots sites to choose from.

When players play on foreign websites, the state loses tax revenue and lottery revenue. Legislative changes have long been expected, and it now appears that the countries have agreed on some proposals.

Player protection should also play a central role in this. On the one hand there should be a central exclusion list and on the other hand a monthly general deposit limit of € 1,000, which should apply to all players. The federal states have agreed on a comprehensive reform that should apply to online casinos, online slots and online poker. This is intended to limit the development and spread of illegal gambling. As part of this restructuring, a central regulatory authority is also to be set up to monitor the activities of licensees. How and when licenses are issued to providers is not yet known.

The associations are due to be heard in February and ministers should then approve the new State Treaty on Gaming. If everything goes according to plan, the new gaming law should then come into force on July 1, 2021

Best German casinos player protection and restrictions on advertising 6ac1x

The new laws on online gambling include a deposit limit of € 1000 a month. However, the limit should not refer to profits. This means that if you make a profit with the deposited credit, regardless of the amount, the amount will not count towards the deposit limit. However, once you pay it out and then pay it back in, the limit will apply.

In addition, the providers should also apply measures for the early detection of problematic gambling. In addition, there should be a central self-exclusion lock file that should be stored at the central supervisory authority.

Advertising for games of chance should be limited to between 11 p.m. and 6 a.m. The regulation should apply to the Internet and radio.

History of gambling in 733qw

The German gambling market has a long and complicated history that goes back to ancient times when the soldiers of the Roman Empire killed time with gambling. The first casino in and possibly the first casino in the world opened in 1720 and this is where the long history of permits and prohibitions began. The modern history of online casinos based in had several important dates that quickly changed the gaming situation in the country.

The Internet casino market was regulated in with the adoption of the Interstate Gambling contract. Before this year, all EUR casinos and gaming activities in were not controlled by the German government. The contract banned the best online casinos and all other online games of chance for German players.

Best german casinos history 491y1w

  • 2010. The European Court of Justice has declared the German gaming market a monopoly. The German gambling legislation has been criticized by the European countries.
  • 2012. The Schleswig-Holstein Land decided to create its own online gaming market and granted licenses to every online casino from that met the requirements, making online gambling in partially legal. The gambling sites that received the Schleswig Holstein licenses included PokerStars, Betfair and Bet365. These are also the best online casinos in . Lucky luck the best online casino in is one of them.
  • 2013. The state has signed the Interstate Gambling Agreement and has entered into the ban on gambling with the rest of the state. The licenses will no longer be issued; the existing licenses will come into force in 2018.
  • 2017. The federal states have approved the new gaming law, which abolishes the state monopoly in the country and will give additional licenses and further sports betting licenses to online casinos that accept German players.
  • The law is due to enter into force on January 1, 201. Nevertheless, the European Commission does not appear to be satisfied with the new gaming law. Therefore, there could be changes in the future if more -approved online casinos come to the country that offer the best online casino experiences.

How do you recognize a dubious online casino? 6h3f65

Casino games safe and serious If you take real money to the casino, you should better distinguish between black sheep and a serious range of games. Comparison portals often speak of how easy it is to differentiate between secure and dubious providers. In fact, it is not that difficult, but for newbies there is still a lot of information that you can not immediately 100 percent due to the high abundance.

Therefore, we would like to go in the other, even easier to recognize direction: How do you actually recognize dubious online casinos?

No license on the website 195r4v

Dubious providers do not hide, fake or show any licensing on the homepage. If there is no license on the start page, all alarm bells should ring. This is a clear sign of an unauthorized range of games that is likely to be equipped with manipulated machines. If a license banner is displayed, a click on the banner is usually sufficient to be forwarded directly to the official license certificate.

Website design is very simple, but non-transparent u2m52

Operators of dubious gambling offers already expect that sooner or later they will be exposed and therefore have to close their casino. For these and other reasons, the website is very simple, but in return only offers very opaque and encrypted information content. For example, no known games are shown or the casino app is ed to see the games offered.

Another advantage of simple designs is that new brands can be developed and brought onto the market with little effort. If an insecure online casino is closed, more are already in the starting blocks of the same operator.

Games by unknown suppliers 27312

Book of Dead, Mega Moolah, Eye of Horus and other games from a well-known provider are not to be found at unsafe providers. The portfolio consists of casino games that nobody knows. The risk of manipulation is all the greater, for example due to falsified payment rates. Realistically speaking, there is no way for players to make a profit. Some providers also offer games that are actually no longer allowed to be played. This includes above all the popular slots from NetEnt, Microgaming Merkur, Novoline and others top-notch game providers.

Unreal bonus 14283z

Best online casinos offer a casino bonus that is transparent and has a realistic bonus balance . Sums of up to € 2500 are acceptable if they come from well-known providers. Free spins without deposit are often part of a wide range of welcome offers. Bad and fraudulent casinos with utopian sums with unreal and conditions. It is not uncommon to promise up to € 5000, which would only have to be implemented 10 times in 60 days. Deadlines of 30 days with an average rollover of 30 are common in the market.

An unsafe casino does not only with a high deposit bonus. Countless free spins are also often offered, which also have a coin value that is far too high per round. We have already encountered such providers during our casino tests. It is simply unrealistic if 300 or 400 free spins are offered at perfect conditions – ideally the same number of free spins without a deposit.

Top Casino Reviews
Spinly Casino Review
Spinly Casino Review

100% bonus on first deposit up to 3,500 µBTC .

PrimeBetz Casino Review
PrimeBetz Casino Review

Welcome Bonus Offer €1500 + 100 Free on best slot games

Wagered Casino Review
Wagered Casino Review

Welcome package 100% up to $1000 on casino games
18+ Gamble Responsibly.

BluVegas Casino with top slot games and live dealers
BluVegas Casino with top slot games and live dealers

Welcome package 100% up to €/$2,000 + 200 Free on Starburst game

Wolfbet Casino and online sports betting site
Wolfbet Casino and online sports betting site

Wolf Race the Wolf Race Today and split the $1,000 prize pool.

Craze​​Play Casino Review
Craze​​Play Casino Review

Welcome package 100% up to €/$2,500 + 250 Free on Book of Dead game
18+ Gamble Responsibly.

Impressario Casino Overview
Impressario Casino Overview

Welcome bonus 100% up to €/$1,000 + 100 Free Spins on Gates of Olympus
18+ Gamble Responsibly.

Vegadream Casino Online Review
Vegadream Casino Online Review

100% bonus on first deposit up to €550.
18+ Gamble Responsibly.

Xspin Crypto online casino Review – Xspion io
Xspin Crypto online casino Review – Xspion io

100% bonus on first deposit up to 0.04 BTC .
18+ Gamble Responsibly.

Gembet Sportsbook and Casino Review
Gembet Sportsbook and Casino Review

20 free credits by Leicester City and 250% welcome bonus
18+ Gamble Responsibly.